The story picks up shortly after the events of the first film. Kyle and his boyfriend (now played by Brett Chukerman, replacing Ryan Carnes from the original) have broken up following a silly lover's quarrel. While nursing his broken heart, Kyle attends an art class where he meets the new nude model: a devastatingly handsome, ambiguously sexual man named Troy (played by Marco Dapper). Troy is a "molded lump of muscle and tan lines" who is questioning his own sexuality—he wants to eventually marry a woman and have children, but isn't entirely sure he's straight.